Each of these rounds has a long history and pedigree of efficacy in the realm of self-defense, so that both are good carry rounds is not in dispute. 357 Magnum self-defense ammo. I think shooting a bear with a pistol caliber is an extremely bad idea. For use in the lower 48 states, a. I've loaded up couple boxes of 158gr cast swc from wheelweights over max charge of red dot. I have personally taken part or witnessed a black bear fall dead to a. I had a book about handgun hunting written in the 70s when I was a kid and it seemed like. The "most likely". At the end of the day all I can say is the last thing Id want to do is try to kill a black bear with any handgun. And no, the bear isn't going to merely snicker at you if he is shot in the head with hardcast from a. We'll be deer hunting in black bear country this fall, and I was thinking about a. 357 Magnum revolver with a DA/SA action and stainless steel medium frame. If I'm packing a rifle anyway I don't worry about a handgun in black bear country. Seriously, any good personal defense handgun caliber will kill a Black Bear,. I wouldn't go any smaller than. Will a 10MM stop a black bear or should I go with a 357 Magnum Hello everyone I was wondering if any of you guys ever encounter a black bear while you was hunting with your 10MM, & if you had to put it down what was the results, also which would be better a 10MM or a 357 Magnum in 1911. 357 is the most street proven self-defense cartridge available. If you go anywhere there are bears, you have a chance of encountering a big one. I'm fully aware that many experienced cougar, boar, and black bear guides carry. Indeed, I love the bear. One black bear was killed, the other was not captured or recovered. The bigger problem might be hitting your target if the situation arose. What if that hungry black bear isn't affected by the spray or what if it's windy and raining, rendering the spray ineffective? Get your damn gun out. It might also aid Not to be Canadian, but I'm not for certain on that. In one instance, the victim fired three shots, only grazing the animal. 357 Mag or 10MM should be fine for black bear. I don't want the extra weight of large frame while I'm hunting and hiking in the mountains. I had a book about handgun hunting written in the 70s when I was a kid and it seemed like. Years back I worked as a forest fire lookout in the Slave Lake area in Alberta. Increasing either, or ideally both, will improve the effectiveness. 24 caliber and with a cartridge at least two inches long. I carry both when out in the cascade mountains, out here there are a lot more predators then you guys have back east. Black bears are a fair bit smaller than browns or grizzlies, so a. 357 magnum ammunition is a popular range and self-defense round among American recreational shooters. 44 mag is probably overkill for most black bears. 357 Magnum came along with a 158 grain bullet at 1500 fps the. 2″ Barrel, full shroud barrel, fiber optics front sight and an adjustable rear sight. I wouldn't be hesitant to use hardcast 255gr SWC loads by Underwood or BB in a Glock, but a good jhp would probably suffice too. best deer black bear rifle is your source for Rebate Sale/Clearance at Gun Store parts and accessories. Although firearmshave failed to protect some users, they aretheonly deterrent that can lethally stop an aggressive bear. 357/180 grain loads are my preference for protection in the field. I use it for deer and he uses it for black bear situations like yours. 357 revolver for bear defense? - What would you take? Going to spend a few days hiking in black bear country. 357 should drop almost any Black Bear, except the forest giants which are rare down south, with a brain hit, but first you should study a Black bear skull, there are some unusual features to the Blackie skull compared to the skulls of Brown and Grizz skulls. "Spray and pray" won't get the job done, regardless of bullet diameter and energy. Top 10 Best. They say the bear spray is actually the best, check out the link. These are the black bear, grizzly bear, brown bear (a sub-species of grizzly) and polar bear. Price Match (5) Ruger GP100 Wiley Clapp 357 Mag. Developed primarily as a law enforcement pistol cartridge, the. In a Big Bear attack there are only two very clear solutions and this is not my opinion but rather based on every bear attack encounter I have read since I was a kid. 357 Magnum provides adequate protection against grizzly bears or not. 357, frequently carry these light and convenient handguns - a Smith & Wesson Model 19 is certainly more packable than a. 357 Sig barrel replacement for around $200. 357 Magnum was used for bear defense, and here is where we find our failure. Shy of grizzlies, 357 magnum or 10mm will be fine. 357 or 10mm. Look who's coming to dinner! A reader heading to Alaska for work (lucky guy!) is properly concerned about grizzly/brown bear "encroachment" and how best to prepare to defend against it. I can go cheap at about $275 at the entry level, but I've had my eye on a Taurus Tracker 627 w/ a 4" barrel for about $500. 357 for black bear protection either. The mid-range trajectory of the. I think the 9mm would be ok for that use. Four of the five uses of the. You are right about the. 45 ACP any day, if those were my only two choices. 357 magnum cartridge to kill a black bear within the Hunting forums, part of the Firearm Forum category; Non-expanding bullets penetrate deeply, and do very little damage. 22 centerfire cartridges as legal ammunition. The 10mm penetration was around 16 inches. pounds of energy at 50 yards. IMO for michigan black bears a 9mm or bigger is more than sufficient. In North America, we have four species of bears. What sets a product apart from the others is the duration and range for which it provides this protection, and how reliably it manages to do so. The Ruger GP-100 ($650) is a 6 shot. Violent attacks usually only last a few minutes but can be prolonged if the victim fights back. We have an over abundance of cougar's. In discussion groups, nay sayers claim that pistols are difficult to use, of insufficient power, and there are numerous instances where people who attempted to use pistols to defend against bears are badly mauled. BEAR LOAD (continued from previous page) Now what about ammunition? For a bear cartridge anything equal to or more powerful than a. Each of these rounds has a long history and pedigree of efficacy in the realm of self-defense, so that both are good carry rounds is not in dispute. 410 for Self Defense. Geographical Survey, was severely mauled by a black bear in the Yukon wilderness. Would you rather have a. It was a scene repeated often and enthusiastically by the Carlson clan for more than 40 years. Everyone knows that snub nose revolvers are inaccurate, so I didn't expect much from the little pocket gun. I found/ordered some 45 LC 260 gr, sjhp,at 1200 fps, from Georgia Arms. In the PNW black bears can get 350-400lbs, we had one that large on the folks' property, photo'd by the camera on the trap provided by WDFW. OK, don't want to start the whole, "Is the 45 acp good enough protection from bear" debate again (it's what I have and isn't changing), but I have read that ball ammo would make more sense for this purpose than hollow points or self-defence rounds due to extra penetration, makes sense to me. But I was thinking about picking up a black powder revolver and curious about its power and accuracy for defense against the very unlikely and mostly make believe bear or cougar attack. Then again, if you have a backpacking partner, all you really need is a 22 to shoot them in the leg with, so that you can get away faster. What are your opinions on. Leave nothing to chance when traveling through bear country. Out of a 6" barrel your pushing 800 Ft. Shop our vast selection and save! Pros 357 rifle for black bear Aesthetically Pleasing, Easy To Install, Good Value, Safe, Tough; 357 rifle for black bear Best Uses Competitive Shooting, Hunting, Self Defense, Tactical, Target Practice. While black bears have much the same physical qualities (normally smaller) of grizzly bears, they GENERALLY have a much different mindset. 357 appears to have more retained. 357 Magnum was used for bear defense, and here is where we find our failure. We pack Deet against mosquitos, Gore-Tex against rain, compass against getting lost —. 357 Magnum loaded with heavy for caliber bonded, based jacketed soft-point or hard cast lead bullets will get the job done. The ole 30-30 is just fine. 357 Magnum or. However, I firmly believe that the. Pistols for Defense against Bears? Failures are Rare. Shy of grizzlies, 357 magnum or 10mm will be fine. Price Match (5) Ruger GP100 Wiley Clapp 357 Mag. 44 Special users tried it, yawned collectively, and went back to their. killed the 400- to 500-pound bear with six shots from his. 338 win mag, not a handgun! But the gun on my belt should all else fail is a 4 inch 44 mag. 38 Special persuasion, it makes a very practical home defense gun. Btw, I've hiked in black bear country for a little over 20 years and never had a problem with bears or anything else. Though the. You aim for his head, the bullet. 357 Magnum self-defense ammo. The 454 is a good one too and could be used in a 460 revolver the same way a 38 goes into a 357. 45, whereupon the bear "stopped and walked into the brush. Our findings suggest that only those proficient in firearms use should rely on them for protection in bear country. where I do astonomy we hear them occasionally. I have killed 4-5 blacks with a 357. Those advocating carrying guns for bear protection provoked an equal and opposite reaction from those who didn't believe guns were a necessary or wise option, at least for a group of teens. What would be the best load for a. • For deer, antelope, mountain lion, and gray wolf, the major change is the addition of. Translation: You need to carry some type of bear protection. 45 for bear "defense". best deer black bear rifle is your source for Rebate Sale/Clearance at Gun Store parts and accessories. 24 caliber and with a cartridge at least two inches long. The owner of Buffalo Bore has an article about this on his site. I've also encountered my first black bear down here, and the Model 327 is what I wear when hiking in the woods. They say the bear spray is actually the best, check out the link. 45 Ruger Redhawk. 44 Magnum will be fine. Well, for me, it depends on what the biggest 4 legged threat is. 357 Mag Revolvers For Sale at Colt New Service New York State Trooper revolver -. The 3 " 410 rounds with 000 Buck shoots 5 nice size projectiles in a nice pattern. I second the bear spray. In a Big Bear attack there are only two very clear solutions and this is not my opinion but rather based on every bear attack encounter I have read since I was a kid. I think the 9mm would be ok for that use. Bear attacks are seldom but once in a while they do happen. You aim for his head, the bullet. In discussion groups, nay sayers claim that pistols are difficult to use, of insufficient power, and there are numerous instances where people who attempted to use pistols to defend against bears are badly mauled. He grabbed me up and took off. Took 3 shots to bring him down, 3 more to kill him. Buffalo Bore loads their ammunition with the highest quality components available to maximize the performance of the ammunition. I watched episode after episode of the series with my grandfather during weekends, and I remember when I was six years old, he bought me a toy revolver. 357 magnum revolver for woods carry. Handgun Defense against Black. Ruger GP100 357 6IN 7RD Stainless Steel Black RBR/WD $ 688. 357 magnum ammunition is a popular range and self-defense round among American recreational shooters. he used a Colt in 38 super and killed a bunch of black bear and cougers out of trees with it. have to defend myself from a charging bear with one of my handguns,357 were desighned to kill humans that's what they are best at my. brown, black and grizzly bear along with caribou. It's doubtful a black bear will even be an issue, and yes a hot. Well, I'll start by telling you I have NEVER been a big fan of the 10mm and I have loved the. 600 Nitro calibers. The best selection of self defense, target, shooting, practice, plinking, surplus, jacketed hollow point/JHP, full metal jacket/FMJ, and frangible Black Bear ammo - buy 1000 rounds or more. For black bear,. 357 Mag is not even a legal cartridge for bear hunting in most states for this very reason. 357 is that most shooters can shoot it more accurately than the bigger magnums. This is particularly true if you're most concerned about defending yourself from a black bear. 357 Magnum knows it’s capable of pushing a 180-grain bullet along with enough horsepower to clobber a buck, black bear, nasty hog or other mid-sized game. Nexus panels are NIJ Level 3A approved and have a V-50 Fragmentation rating in excess of 630 meters per second. As it happens, there are some limited instances of these rounds being used successfully on animals. We pack Deet against mosquitos, Gore-Tex against rain, compass against getting lost —. Conversely, if your first line of defense is a gunshot, and you shoot at the bear, the results will almost always be more severe. 40 S&W, 10MM,. 44 magnum for bear defense? Scenario: Your are bowhunting in Montana. After years of backpacking, I was actually charged by a black bear. I was originally thinking a Sig Sauer p220 chambered in 10mm, but I have recently been rethinking maybe a. As stated, I wouldn't think a. 9", and expanded to 0. The bear is 7 seconds form being on top of you. 45 would be another, much lighter and more packable, option for bear protection. I watched episode after episode of the series with my grandfather during weekends, and I remember when I was six years old, he bought me a toy revolver. The thick-skinned nature of bears makes them difficult to penetrate without a large caliber gun and a heavy bullet. 338 win mag, not a handgun! But the gun on my belt should all else fail is a 4 inch 44 mag. With black bear, a. However, like the. What it’s like to take a bear defense course. I would limit the range to <50yds and stick to heavy lead bullets to be safe though. Top 10 Best. 357 & 44 Mag Product Overview from Hornady Black Bear Cartridges and Calibers by Randy Tyler Freel explains the most important aspects of carrying a handgun as defense in bear country. by Ron Spomer. But if you search the internet enough you can find a study that will say what you wish. 357s great strengths, its range, is wasted, and may even be a liability in the urban environment. Black Bear Energy Spray. What load/ammo would likely stop an angry black bear or stalking cougar or at least make it wish it were somewhere else?. Would any of these work on a black bear and if so which caliber. Shop the best price per round on 357 Magnum now!. 357 magnum bear guns and bear loads. 357 Mag in a pinch for bear if its not a. 44 may be enough gun if proficient at shooting but after talking to lots of fish and game enforcement in AK, most would laught at a. Based on what I own, I’d go with a Glock 21 or my Ruger 44 with 5” barrel. Source: 1911Forum, Reddit AR-15. "Spray and pray" won't get the job done, regardless of bullet diameter and energy. The best selection of self defense, target, shooting, practice, plinking, surplus, jacketed hollow point/JHP, full metal jacket/FMJ, and frangible Black Bear ammo - buy 1000 rounds or more. 40 S&W during the Muskingum County Animal Farm incident. Friday, July 30, 2010 10:29:00 AM. I wouldn't go any smaller than. There were three instances in which. All of this research has convinced me that the 10MM Auto in the Glock platform anyway, is "on all fours" with heavy 357 Magnum loads, factory 41 Magnum loads and the Garrett Cartridges (T) 44 Magnum Defender loads for Field Protection and Self-Defense in Alaska. 9mm for black bear? This is a discussion on 9mm for black bear? within the Ammo and Reloading forums, part of the Gun Forum category; Without arguing the merits of carrying a gun while backpacking (a whole topic in and of itself), I'm curious what round you guys would pick. However, the purpose of this article is to suggest better and more reliable firearm choices for protection in bear country. killed the 400- to 500-pound bear with six shots from his. 357 magnum jacketed hollow point ammo is a great choice for folks that need a powerful self-defense round. This makes sense, of course, as pure stopping power goes a long way when you're trying to stay alive in the face of a charging bear. 44 mag velocities if the revolver is of good quality. Oldtime black bear hunters say that any load that throws at least a 200-grain or bigger solid bullet at 1000 fps or more will take any bear in the woods. The single-action revolver has been around for 140 years. What it’s like to take a bear defense course. A lot of folks carry the 44 mag as well, but you dont need all that for the bears. Four of the five uses of the. 357 magnum in 2010, and one case involving a black bear and a. My fav wheel gun is my. Here is what I use in a 357 Mag 10 inch T/C Contender and my Bro in a 4 inch S&W Mod 28. Bear defense plays an important part in Alaska because bear attacks, as expected, are common. The Ruger GP-100 ($650) is a 6 shot. Sun Protection & Apparel HSM Bear Load Handgun Ammo -. killed the 400- to 500-pound bear with six shots from his. 357, actually treading on the heels of the. The mid-range trajectory of the. 357 mag over the. trying to force their dreams on the reality of Alaska. The buying public is voting for revolvers and buying them in great numbers. Buffalo Bore loads their ammunition with the highest quality components available to maximize the performance of the ammunition. 357 magnum ammunition is a popular range and self-defense round among American recreational shooters. 357 Mag that features a longer 4. 357 Magnum cartridge. Foggy Mountain black bear. Black bears usually try. trying to force their dreams on the reality of Alaska. 10mm for Grizzly protection I've done it several times with short barreled 357 mag revolver, S+W Sigma in 40 S+W, 41 mag, 44 mag, 45 Colt and 480 Ruger handguns. 5 Powerful Handguns for Wilderness Protection. Unless there's a food and one gets between the food and the bear, they tend to not be a problem. 357 rifle is suited for almost any duty you can cook up, short of long-range tasks. 357 Mag that features a longer 4. Striving to avoid bear, being as they say, "bear aware", making noise and observing ones surroundings can many times alleviate any confrontation from occurring. I'd suggest at least 158 grain hardcast instead of jacketed bullets as they offer better penetration. The only thing that makes the. Might want to look at those. 178) to 250 grain (SD. But on Saturday, Sept. Ruger has a new. Fortunately, I scared the bear enough with a branch at the last minute. 3X18 Makarov. But if you search the internet enough you can find a study that will say what you wish. The bigger problem might be hitting your target if the situation arose. But, if I had a 357 with at least a 6 inch barrel, and didn't want to spend the money on something else, I would not feel undergunned with it on a black bear. trying to force their dreams on the reality of Alaska. At this point I feel like I would be more effective with the 10mm's I shoot better and more often. I've read several posts that suggest nothing less than a 357 mag as a back up bear gun, and shun the 40 or 45 for this. The most common recommended size for hunting black bear is a 30+ caliber round, at least 200 grain, and at least 1000 fps. 357 Magnum vs 9mm. Loaded with hollow points in either. In one instance, the victim fired three shots, only grazing the animal. We also shoot it in our Marlin 1894CS. The Case For The 357 Magnum "The All-Around Handgun Cartridge?" Phil Shoemaker once wrote a very controversial article for Handloader magazine in which he confessed that his personal choice for a backup handgun, while guiding clients for Brown Bear, was a Smith and Wesson Model 60 in 357 Magnum. But for brown bear or grizzly the baseline caliber would be a 44 mag. 3" HB Stainless Steel Novak Re $ 796. 357 performance. Handgun Defense against Black. 357 mag out of a four inch barrel was adequate enough for self defense against a mountain lion or a large black bear? I know being attacked by either animal is rare, but I would still like all bases covered just incase. I'd suggest at least 158 grain hardcast instead of jacketed bullets as they offer better penetration. Nearly 20 years ago, I picked up a like-new Ruger Speed Six 357 for $125. 87-2”, as. I have a Marlin 1894 SS 44 mag and a Taurus model 44 SS 4" barrel. For use in the lower 48 states, a. He wanted to take his cat camping with him, do you guys actually think hell see a bear in the woods?. August 10, 2015. A black bear can be taken down by either, it's not ideal, but grizzlies have been taken out with those calibers too and it can be done with a little luck. For a close encounter with a Griz or large Black bear I would have a 12 gauge loaded with rifled slugs,without a plug in the gun. 357 appears to have more retained. HSM's Bear Load delivers incredible terminal performance on the biggest, angriest and most aggressive animals when it matters most. I watched episode after episode of the series with my grandfather during weekends, and I remember when I was six years old, he bought me a toy revolver. 357 mag with 200g hardcast at 1250fps or more, depending on barrel length. 357 hardcast will penetrate a black bear skull even from a snub. I will be using a 170 Gr. The best selection of self defense, target, shooting, practice, plinking, surplus, jacketed hollow point/JHP, full metal jacket/FMJ, and frangible Black Bear ammo - buy 1000 rounds or more. 357 Magnum was used for bear defense, and here is where we find our failure. That being said, any magnum level pistol is a good choice against black bear. Black Bear Energy Spray. Handgun rounds in the. Any of you have some suggestions for a happy medium rifle caliber which I can hunt partridge with while perhaps dissuade a black bear's curiosity or even attack without having to change ammo midway?. 357 rifle for black bear is your source for Rebate Sale/Clearance at Gun Store parts and accessories. Conversely, if your first line of defense is a gunshot, and you shoot at the bear, the results will almost always be more severe. In a perfect world I would have a Semi-Auto shotgun loaded with slugs too. These are the black bear, grizzly bear, brown bear (a sub-species of grizzly) and polar bear. 357 magnum jacketed hollow point ammo is a great choice for folks that need a powerful self-defense round. I think the 9mm would be ok for that use. However, the purpose of this article is to suggest better and more reliable firearm choices for protection in bear country. With hot loads it is just a touch below a 41 magnum and outshines the 357. In reality you are highly unlikely to have a bear problem. This round should take down a black bear. Shoot your gun often, and be sure that your carry method offers you quick access when you need it most. Violent attacks usually only last a few minutes but can be prolonged if the victim fights back. 357 mag for the kinds of threat I might run into in the Oregon/Washington forests (animal or human). When it comes to bear-busting power, you have to have at least a. Guns of The Terminator Movies. 357 for bear defense and felt fine, knowing I wouldnt use it but at near point blank ranges aiming at the bears. 45 Super kill a black bear, absolutely. killed the 400- to 500-pound bear with six shots from his. But as a self-protection gun in an area with black bear as the largest predator, i'd consider a. 41 Magnum up to the. This cartridge's deep penetration is more than capable of stopping a charging bear with good shot placement. The Kimber K6s revolver with 3” barrel is an excellent duty and home defense firearm – but can prove itself invaluable for campers, hikers, and hunters in while trekking through bear country. Top 10 Best. "The SP101 has been an extremely popular small frame revolver since its inception in 1988, but it has always featured a short barrel and minimal sights," said Chris Killoy, Ruger Vice. My concern is with the ballistics of the magnum round out of a 2 or 3" barrel. "Spray and pray" won't get the job done, regardless of bullet diameter and energy. If you wanted to change your rifle then get one in the cal. Look at the velocity and energy figures. I would limit the range to <50yds and stick to heavy lead bullets to be safe though. 22 but see traces of black bear activity. In black bear country I don't think I'd pack the 4oz of the light most times though. 357 magnum for black bear defense, 357 jsp for black bear defense, 357 mag ammo for animal defense, 357 magnum ammo for bears, 357 magnum for black bear defense, 357 magnum vs black bear, best 357 ammo for bear, best 357 ammo for bear defense, best 357 ammo for black bear protection, smith and wesson vcomp 357 for defense. Shoot your gun often, and be sure that your carry method offers you quick access when you need it most. Nexus panels are NIJ Level 3A approved and have a V-50 Fragmentation rating in excess of 630 meters per second. Especially when shooting hard cast or other non-expanding bullets, hunters can rely on a. Technologically advanced powders push the premium, hard-cast bullets at significantly higher velocities for terminal energy superior to standard loads. The best types of bear guns fall into two distinct categories; guns for hunting and guns for self-defense. If you go anywhere there are bears, you have a chance of encountering a big one. I am NOT AT ALL much for firearms, so don't kick me in my teeth for asking. 357 mag performance, what I mean is "entry-level". 2″ barrel looks like a good "woods gun" to me. The people telling you that you have no reason to fear bears are, I assume relating thier experience. Narrow "drill bore" wound tracts mean little trauma, and little trauma means little bleeding, and slow. 338 win mag, not a handgun! But the gun on my belt should all else fail is a 4 inch 44 mag. In black bear country I don't think I'd pack the 4oz of the light most times though. I hunt partridge with my. 44 magnum for bear defense? Scenario: Your are bowhunting in Montana. Pistols for Defense against Bears? Failures are Rare. 357 6 shot revolver, or a 15 shot Glock 20 (10mm auto)? What about the same. With black bear, a. 357 Magnum provides adequate protection against grizzly bears or not. For the purpose of self-defense, the largest caliber, most portable gun is ideal. Alaska Geologist Pistol Defense failure June 20, 2010, Grizzly Bear,. 357 performance. 380) are a bit weak the most popular are. Do you mean a grizzly bear? I have black bear in my area (Pennsylvania), but they tend to stay away from people and for the most part, are not that large (relatively speaking!). He wanted to take his cat camping with him, do you guys actually think hell see a bear in the woods?. Especially when shooting hard cast or other non-expanding bullets, hunters can rely on a. 357 Magnum is the 125 grain JHP at 1,450 FPS from a four-inch barrel revolver. I for one sleep like a brick, especially after hiking all day. The Incredible Responsibility of Being. Just to keep on topic and not hijack this thread the 357 makes a dandy black bear protection gun. I don't know how the physiology of a cougar or bear compared to a human when considering stopping power. 24 caliber and with a cartridge at least two inches long. Also, going to have bear spray as a primary defense over having to shoot a bear. Nearly 20 years ago, I picked up a like-new Ruger Speed Six 357 for $125. If you wanted to change your rifle then get one in the cal. I had gritty hounds that would grab ass, so the action is fast. There were three instances in which. Handgun rounds in the. 44 may be enough gun if proficient at shooting but after talking to lots of fish and game enforcement in AK, most would laught at a. 357 Magnum provides adequate protection against grizzly bears or not. I carry a 10mm Glock with 200 grain xtp or WFNGC.